I just completed Momodi's Charming Chokers and didn't receive it :( . My rating was 339 so maybe I was too high, though I wouldn't say my reward was better then an atelope horn which can't be received else where... I got 3 soiled fumurs besides the standard reward of 3 copper ingots. I'm wondering if it matters which version of the quest you do. (different numbers of the item requested have different base rewards of, copper ingots, brass ingots, silver etc, or elctrum) It makes me sad to have wasted a leve.
--
OK, Just completed A mother's Jewelery. This one was to complete 4 bone rings with 6 mats and had a set reward of silver ingots. My completion rating was 359 and I received 3 horns. Post on YG says the bonus is 1,2 or 3 extra mats based on 100+ 200+ and 300+ respective ratings and that bonus mat is random selection of solid femurs, antelope horns, or white coral. I'm still going with theory that it has to do with how many items are requested and which base reward is offered. Will update if more info.
--
Ok Momodi's Charming Chokers again. This time the requested 4 items quest, with silver ingot base reward. 410 rating /cheer! . 4 Antelope horn bonus reward received. /cheer! lol. Supports my theory, though 3 tries on 2 tests doesn't prove anything, I am hopefull.
Edited, Nov 25th 2010 12:10pm by firefreet
Edited, Nov 25th 2010 3:27pm by firefreet

Results from Primary Tool
Results from Secondary Tool