Forum Settings
       
Reply To Thread

Red Mage in 4.0?Follow

#1 Jun 14 2016 at 1:13 AM Rating: Good
Scholar
48 posts
Apologize if this has already been asked on this forum alone like eleventy billion times already, but...

It's been heavily hinted that Red Mage will be included in the next expansion (which is probably due to be officially announced any day now). I'm personally hoping it will be, as I have to admit that in defiance of popular opinion I am very fond of that FF Job in general.

Many things made the FFXI RDM - the Enfeebling spells, the whole concept, the ease of soloing. On the flip side, though, many broke it, including the addition of several far superior hybrid "Advanced" Jobs, the ultimate pigeonholing into a support role, and the lacking abilities compared to WHM/BLM/WAR.

Now that FFXIV has moved away from base classes, I think they could easily fit RDM as a Rapier-wielding Job, probably as a melee dps Discipline of Magic. Even more interesting would be the storyline, as it could open some exciting new avenues as to how and why they existed, and exploring the "balance" of White and Black Magic in more depth (as CNJs/WHMs and THMs/BLMs seem to always be at odds in the Eorzean universe).

So if RDM does indeed make it in the 4.0 expansion, would you be excited to level it up on your character right away? Or is there some other Job you'd rather see instead? (Blue Mage? Geomancer?)

Edited, Jun 14th 2016 3:15am by JFrombaugh
#2 Jun 14 2016 at 1:45 AM Rating: Good
**
863 posts
Even if there have been some hints I am not sure we will see it. If anything I think SAM has been hinted at more and either way I doubt we will get an announcement about new jobs before fanfests. They have said E3 will be about patch 3.3 and deepest dungeon and I don't think they will surprise us with much aside from maybe confirming the expansion in some way. As for new jobs I think so many want RDM that it would be a good choice if they can manage to make an interesting version of it. I would personally love BLU but again it depends on implementation entirely. Also I really hope they make a more interesting healer this time around, the game really needs it.
#3 Jun 14 2016 at 9:30 AM Rating: Decent
Scholar
***
1,726 posts
4.0? is that gong to be a pay expansion?
Sorry have not played in a while or kept up much...
RDM would be something I would be interested in.. I could give a rats a## about another DD class with a stupid rotation and really is no different than any other DD class..

Maybe with red mage things can change from a rotation to actually reacting to the situation.
I really did Not play much RDM till the end of FFXI for me but I enjoyed it.

I played mainly WHM like in FFXI just like FFXIV.. FFXIV there is too much hate against whm where anything that happens is always the WHM fault. SE tries to make a game harder by adding more dodging but all it does it make it harder for a whm not DD classes. A whm can not heal while dodging So more dodging means less time to heal and if a dd or tank decides he aint going to move it means more healing. So basically anytime they make a battle harder it really is just mainly on the whm since this game is full of the laziest players.

I wonder if they did would it be a new healer class?
This game certainly does not need another DD class..



Edited, Jun 14th 2016 11:33am by Nashred
____________________________
FFXI: Nashred
Server: Phoenix

FFXIV : Sir Nashred
server: Ultros
#4 Jun 14 2016 at 12:56 PM Rating: Good
Scholar
48 posts
Belcrono wrote:
As for new jobs I think so many want RDM that it would be a good choice if they can manage to make an interesting version of it.


I feel that while the whole concept of the Red Mage is just fantastic, it could have been executed with so much more elegance, with so much more chique, in XIV than it actually has been in XI.

The thing is, the "jack-of'all-trades" ability of XI RDM wasn't as good as we're led to believe. In many cases in a group you'd be relegated to a support role regardless of your sub-job, you could help out with DPS or Healing depending on whether you Subbed WHM or BLM, but it really isn't as all-rounded and able to fill multiple roles as perhaps it should've been.

Instead, for XIV's RDM, I would personally like to see something similar to Enhance Shammy from WoW or Harbinger from Rift. He could have some passive skill that allows his melee attacks to benefit from Intelligence while also setting up combos that involve casting short-range spells similar to NIN's Ninjutsu. He could also learn the En- and Spikes lines of spells for some added buffs and effects.

The melee aspect of XI's RDM troubled me. To me, it seems to be sword skills for the sake of sword skills. I've read through some of the Job guides written in the early days of FFXI and it seems like it was only recently that they actually buffed RDM's sword skill rating/damage to actually make it viable as an alternative to casting Black Magic.

Belcrono wrote:
Also I really hope they make a more interesting healer this time around, the game really needs it.


Personally I would like to see Geomancer be the new Healer (maybe some kind of Far Eastern Astrologian that uses a new mechanic?). GEO uses a Bell as its weapon so there'd be no problem with the Armory system.
#5 Jun 14 2016 at 1:46 PM Rating: Good
Scholar
Avatar
*****
12,804 posts
Though, XIV is a "rotation" based MMO, which would further niche RDM to a certain role, since if it's a healer, it HAS to play like WHM/SCH/AST with it's own unique version of x heal, as per the XIV design. If it's a caster, it HAS to play like BLM or SMN. If it's a melee, it HAS to play like MNK, NIN or DRG. If it's a sword user it HAS to play like Gladiator and so on. So unless they completely change the gameplay, RDM that we know of it in FF/FFXI isn't possible sadly.

It'd be interesting to see what they do, but after seeing Dark Knight, I don't know...as much as I love DRK, just..could have been so better if it at least had "Dark Magic" or something. So many times I wish I could self-heal like a PLD or WAR...but I have nothing. Abyssal Drain? Enjoy sucking away all of that MP for minimal heal, especially on single target lol. Bloodbath? Doesn't outweight the damage going out.

As for XI RDM, it was a pretty good jack of all trades, the issue is, much like NInja, the community had its own idea for it. RDM melee was fine but like even THF, it wasn't suited for high def/eva mobs in the early days. it was an amazing crowd control, since a lot of people compare it to the "RDM of the offline titles" when even BLM could use daggers in older FF games, but you never really see them complain about wanting to melee more..which the one time they did, SE gave them access to Scythes and it didn't change much.

So honestly, as much as I love RDM, I think this game need to significantly change at 4.0, maybe they're using deep dungeon to test some concepts.
____________________________

#6 Jun 14 2016 at 2:00 PM Rating: Decent
Scholar
****
4,511 posts
Well, Samurai is pretty much a given since we already have the class trainer telling you she will be back to teach you.

Beastmasters have been around a while too in XIV as an enemy class, and even more so in the latest dungeon. That would be on the list too.

I dont see any of the "hints" towards RDM though? Maybe that's just wishful thinking. Cant think of any npc, job or quest that has that. Nor do i really see a way to implement it since we are bound to "DPS", "Tank" and "Healer" roles.
____________________________
[XI] Surivere of Valefor
[XIV] Sir Surian Bedivere of Behemoth
http://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/2401553/
#7 Jun 14 2016 at 2:42 PM Rating: Good
****
5,722 posts
In a shocking event, I actually agree with Hio. I just don't see SE being able to implement RDM into the game in it's current form. Not in the manner that people want anyway.

Red Mage, historically, is a hybrid job. It's THE hybrid job in most FF games. Problem is that roles in FFXIV are highly specialized. The game doesn't have a place for a hybrid. They could make RDM a melee DPS with some weaponskills that look like magic, or a healer, or even a tank, but is that really what people want when they say they want to play a Red Mage?
____________________________
75 Rabbit/75 Sheep/75 Coeurl/75 Eft/75 Raptor/75 Hippogryph/75 Puk
75 Scorpion/75 Wamoura/75 Pixie/75 Peiste/64 Sabotender
51 Bird/41 Mandragora/40 Bee/37 Crawler/37 Bat

Items no one cares about: O
Missions no one cares about: O
Crafts no one cares about: O
#8 Jun 14 2016 at 3:35 PM Rating: Excellent
For RDM to work as a hybrid, it would have to be an all-new class type that took the place of a DPS role in party setups. I do think this could work, though. Perhaps the fourth spot in four-man dungeons could be filled with either a hybrid or DPS, based on what's in the DF.

I think it's totally doable, but yeah, would have to be done with a new expansion when the level cap goes up and effectively resets the content.
____________________________
Thayos Redblade
Jormungandr
Hyperion
#9 Jun 14 2016 at 8:27 PM Rating: Good
Guru
Avatar
*****
11,143 posts
You won't find me disagreeing that SE dropped the ball with RDM in XI. Unfortunately, when you evoke the "Jack of all trades" axiom when it comes to MMOs, "suck at them all" is the unspoken suffix since you'll inevitably have "specialists" get antsy that someone dares compete while having other tricks up their sleeve. Of course, what SE did with XI isn't entirely pertinent here, presuming they don't just seek to recreate their mistakes.

When I envision RDM for XIV, however, I inevitably see it as a DPS/Support hybrid. At the basic level, you'd have a sword combo that gains steps as you level. Something like Fast Blade > Death Blossom > Chant du Cygne could be throwbacks in name and graphic. FB could just be basic damage, DB does damage and increases the amount of damage a mob would take from magical attacks, then CdC could increase damage from physical sources for a time. They could also add some other abilities to branch off FB for HP/MP recovery.

Loosely covering the martial side, we then look at the magical. The trick here is to not fall into XI's trap where the melee is never, ever used. Further, the job honestly can't hope to replace a WHM or SCH for the healing slot. And as is, XIV has handled the elements in a funky way, so you can't really be all "give them a tier less than the specialist" too. Single-target buffs are also something I'd call a gameplay no-no, which means if we want some form of Haste and Refresh, it has to come in an AoE form. But overall, I'm not against a basic cure. A unique nuke type that tiers up would be a basic magic damage solution. A DoT or two also wouldn't be unheard of.

Lastly, I guess that leaves the Enspell concept. This is where they could technically do funky things with (de)buffs based on what your party needs. They'd be applied to both auto attacks and melee abilities, possibly stackable. If they go that route, they could also gain an ability to consume stacks for an additional effect and/or damage.

A rough wish list, sure, but I think those hoping for old school RDM/NIN or the Pink Mage are looking in the wrong place when it comes to humoring the job concept.
____________________________
Violence good. **** bad. Yay America.
#10 Jun 15 2016 at 5:00 AM Rating: Good
**
863 posts
Out of curiosity Seriha could you elaborate a little about the "suck at them all" part? I never felt like that was the case in XI (Not sure how it is past 75). I mean it just feels like it depends on how you define roles.

In FFXIV I feel it is pretty clearly DD, Healer, Tank whereas in XI I never felt that to the same extent. To me it always felt a lot more fluid/flexible because some jobs could fit several of those roles at the same time. Now if you said RDM sucked at being a DPS then I would agree of course, but I mean they could tank, heal/support, kite solo NM, melee solo NM/farm. To me that means they could heal really well but not in all situations, they could melee but not in all situations etc. Now some people might have wanted RDM melee to be more prominent and I can understand that, but it does not mean I necessarily think they should therefore be able to melee in every situation or have to do it to be played optimally always.

In XIV it would have to fit one of the roles DD, Healer; Tank a lot more rigidly and be balanced with the other jobs in that category, but I think RDM was really well done in XI and fit perfectly into the type of game that XI was where you didn't need to fit a defined role in the same sense as XIV. Like I said though of course they could have made melee a bit stronger or a bigger part of RDM playstyle, but I was very happy with how it was and would not have wanted it for myself, but rather because some others wanted it so badly.
#11 Jun 15 2016 at 6:55 AM Rating: Decent
Scholar
Avatar
*****
12,804 posts
Yeah, I'm not sure how 'jack of all trades' translates to sucks at them all when RDM is one of the most powerful jobs in XI to the point they literally needed no updates, which I know upset some RDMs during XI's run when everyone else was getting updates but for the longest period of time a good RDM was the only job that could properly debuff and crowd control certain content. SCH and GEO eventually came into the scene but RDM to this day is still the only job that could solo the Sky gods back in the prime of 75 cap era...if that's "sucking" then yeah, RDM truly needed nothing lol.

I mean, it sucks RDM weren't melee gods ontop of being amazing casters but you had Black Mage and Blue Mage to fit those roles in 75 cap era then later tossed in Geomancer which has melee on par of RDM and WHM (since it uses clubs and has access to basically every club WS.)

So unless XIV adds in the ability to be a hybrid job and not locked down to a "rotation" RDM, GEO, BLU, DNC and so on I wouldn't want them to add because these jobs above all were more of a "fit the situation" rather than queue up for DF as x role. I mean, look at the Warrior and Ninja situation - if you have both present, let alone in an alliance with a couple of them, they have debuffs that override each other.

Why? Why couldn't War have it's debuff, then NIN have a separate different that worked together, rather than WAR/DRK/NIN/MNK having essentially the same debuff skill thus actually making part of your toolset worthless in a raid situation? I'd love to see what they can come up with, but I'd want the game to actually change before they even think of complex jobs being added. Every other MMO has "Tank/DPS/Heal/Support" slots and some have "Tank/DPS/Heal/Support (or Hybrid or "free")" slots.

____________________________

#12 Jun 15 2016 at 8:20 AM Rating: Decent
Scholar
Avatar
20 posts
Quote:

So if RDM does indeed make it in the 4.0 expansion, would you be excited to level it up on your character right away?


Depends. I doubt they'd let red mage to (properly) be both healer and caster at once, which is the job's appeal to me.

Quote:
Or is there some other Job you'd rather see instead? (Blue Mage? Geomancer?)


Summoner. A proper summoner.
#13 Jun 15 2016 at 9:37 AM Rating: Good
Sage
**
755 posts
Holhorse wrote:
Quote:

So if RDM does indeed make it in the 4.0 expansion, would you be excited to level it up on your character right away?


Depends. I doubt they'd let red mage to (properly) be both healer and caster at once, which is the job's appeal to me.

Quote:
Or is there some other Job you'd rather see instead? (Blue Mage? Geomancer?)


Summoner. A proper summoner.


Correct me if I'm wrong, but currently SMN is a lot like RDM from FFXI. I mean they enfeeble and assist healing. They just use a pet instead of a sword. I'd love to have a RDM here, but it would need to bring something new to the party.
____________________________
I think you've been smoking the Moko...
http://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/350413/
http://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/1628942/
http://www.nerdist.com/
Angus of Cerberus (retired)
#14 Jun 15 2016 at 9:46 AM Rating: Decent
Scholar
Avatar
*****
12,804 posts
SMN in XIV is more like a Warlock from WoW than anything. So while it can assist heal (realistically main heal in early dungeons) but due to the INT base the only heal it has access to is pretty terrible. it'd be like asking a BLM to main heal with Physick.

If SMN mimicked XI's SMN Garuda egi for example would also be able to assist in healing and party support.
____________________________

#15 Jun 15 2016 at 10:28 AM Rating: Excellent
I'd totally play as a melee-heavy rdm with white/black enspells and little-to-no healing.
____________________________
Thayos Redblade
Jormungandr
Hyperion
#16 Jun 15 2016 at 10:56 AM Rating: Good
****
5,722 posts
Belcrono wrote:
Out of curiosity Seriha could you elaborate a little about the "suck at them all" part? I never felt like that was the case in XI (Not sure how it is past 75). I mean it just feels like it depends on how you define roles.

Suck is a strong word but the idea isn't wrong. Yeah, RDMs weren't bad at anything, but in MMO terms "not bad" may was well be worthless when you could have "great" instead. RDMs were really great at a few specific things and decent at everything else. Decent is fine when you're solo but meaningless in a party setting when people want efficiency.

But RDMs can heal, nuke, melee, tank, etc, all with just a quick gear swap! Yeah, but did anyone actually let you do any of those things? I spent a lot of years as a 75 RDM and my memories mostly involve main heal or GTFO. In a party I was there for cure, haste, refresh, sleep, and occasionally chainspell>stun. The only time I got to do other stuff was solo or messing around in small groups.
____________________________
75 Rabbit/75 Sheep/75 Coeurl/75 Eft/75 Raptor/75 Hippogryph/75 Puk
75 Scorpion/75 Wamoura/75 Pixie/75 Peiste/64 Sabotender
51 Bird/41 Mandragora/40 Bee/37 Crawler/37 Bat

Items no one cares about: O
Missions no one cares about: O
Crafts no one cares about: O
#17 Jun 15 2016 at 11:06 AM Rating: Decent
Scholar
Avatar
*****
12,804 posts
It really depended on the group you rolled with. We actually used a RDM tank a few times even before the Sleep II enmity glitch because their stubborness of dying rivals DNC and quite frankly, our PLD was just being lazy those raiding days so since DNC wasn't really up to par for tanking yet, we went with the next best thing, since they too could also kite.

So the "general community" didn't let a RDM do all it could, but in terms of design it could do a **** of a lot which is why it went untouched for years while every other job got adjustments. Aside SE removing Cure V, Regen II and Marksmanship/Gun access to RDM in the early days, they honestly had RDM "perfect" for what it was. It was SMN that was never in a good spot in the early days.

Them slapping in the magic resistance patch though, that's when RDM actually started to suffer, but also exceed because only they were able to properly debuff certain NMs for quite some time.
____________________________

#18 Jun 15 2016 at 11:43 AM Rating: Decent
**
438 posts
I'd like to see RDM, SAM, and RUN in 4.0 and the way I want them to unlock is:

(Healer) Red Mage= must have a lvl 60 WHM and BLM
(Melee DPS, because they did ranged dps in HW) Samurai= must have a lvl 60 WAR and NIN
(Tank) Runefencer= must have a lvl 60 PLD and...ummm.....BLM again? SMN?
____________________________
Star Swirl on Behemoth AKA Best-hemoth AKA The Cool Kid's Table----60AST, 60WHM, 60SCH/SMN, 60BLM, 60MNK, 38 PLD, 34DRG, 31NIN, 27MRD
FFXI- Derpypony on Asura
Check out the Dream Network, a Twitch.tv community for XIV fans, featuring notable streamers like Mr. Happy, MTQcapture, Rahhzay, and Slyakagreyfox! http://dreamnetwork.tv/forum/index.php
Then maybe check out myself, EquestriaGuy, on twitch at http://www.twitch.tv/equestriaguy


#19 Jun 15 2016 at 11:59 AM Rating: Good
****
5,722 posts
I'm still waiting for beast and/or puppetmaster. Give me a physical pet job already!
____________________________
75 Rabbit/75 Sheep/75 Coeurl/75 Eft/75 Raptor/75 Hippogryph/75 Puk
75 Scorpion/75 Wamoura/75 Pixie/75 Peiste/64 Sabotender
51 Bird/41 Mandragora/40 Bee/37 Crawler/37 Bat

Items no one cares about: O
Missions no one cares about: O
Crafts no one cares about: O
#20 Jun 15 2016 at 12:02 PM Rating: Good
**
438 posts
Karlina wrote:
I'm still waiting for beast and/or puppetmaster. Give me a physical pet job already!


The game definitely needs this. I think they'd go with a PUP since they're melee if I'm not mistaken, and I doubt they'd want to introduce a ranged dps 2 xpacs in a row.

Edited, Jun 15th 2016 2:04pm by garethrogue
____________________________
Star Swirl on Behemoth AKA Best-hemoth AKA The Cool Kid's Table----60AST, 60WHM, 60SCH/SMN, 60BLM, 60MNK, 38 PLD, 34DRG, 31NIN, 27MRD
FFXI- Derpypony on Asura
Check out the Dream Network, a Twitch.tv community for XIV fans, featuring notable streamers like Mr. Happy, MTQcapture, Rahhzay, and Slyakagreyfox! http://dreamnetwork.tv/forum/index.php
Then maybe check out myself, EquestriaGuy, on twitch at http://www.twitch.tv/equestriaguy


#21 Jun 15 2016 at 1:26 PM Rating: Decent
Scholar
Avatar
20 posts
AngusX wrote:
Holhorse wrote:
Quote:

So if RDM does indeed make it in the 4.0 expansion, would you be excited to level it up on your character right away?


Depends. I doubt they'd let red mage to (properly) be both healer and caster at once, which is the job's appeal to me.

Quote:
Or is there some other Job you'd rather see instead? (Blue Mage? Geomancer?)


Summoner. A proper summoner.


Correct me if I'm wrong, but currently SMN is a lot like RDM from FFXI. I mean they enfeeble and assist healing. They just use a pet instead of a sword. I'd love to have a RDM here, but it would need to bring something new to the party.


I wasn't a XI player so I don't know, but to me the ideal would be SMN getting streamlined (replacing support options with DPS options through their pets) and RDM maybe taking that role if people want, so both sides can be more like their classic versions.

These times I think Yoshida should be less stubborn and just add specs, skill trees, etc. Right now we have 2 casters and 3 melee, if RDM ends as melee we'll have an imbalance, if they're casters then I know a lot of people will be disappointed. So just let us choose.
#22 Jun 15 2016 at 1:43 PM Rating: Good
***
3,702 posts
Quote:
I wasn't a XI player so I don't know, but to me the ideal would be SMN getting streamlined (replacing support options with DPS options through their pets) and RDM maybe taking that role if people want, so both sides can be more like their classic versions.


But classic summoners ARE hybrid support/dps. It's hard to express that in XIV which doesn't recognize a support role, but it's pretty apparent when you look at past Final Fantasy games that while summoners have their heavy dps abilities, most of what they do is support oriented.

FFV's summoner was arguably more useful putting up Golem shields than it was summoning Bahamut. FF6, 7 and 8's summons ran the gamut from healing to utility to damage. FF9's two summoners both had powerful white magic backing them up which they tended to use a lot more frequently than their summons. FF10's summoner WAS a white mage... she was your only one unless you did some wacky sphere grid shenanigans. FF11's SMN had a mix of support and dps abilities on their summons.

It's rare that a summoner has been a pure dps. I can only really think of one and it's Rydia, and even then it's only Rydia when she returns to your party later in the game. When you get her she's some kind of weirdo omni-mage that can do everything albeit not very well.
____________________________
svlyons wrote:
If random outcomes aren't acceptable to you, then don't play with random people.
#23 Jun 15 2016 at 8:34 PM Rating: Good
Guru
Avatar
*****
11,143 posts
Karlina wrote:
Belcrono wrote:
Out of curiosity Seriha could you elaborate a little about the "suck at them all" part? I never felt like that was the case in XI (Not sure how it is past 75). I mean it just feels like it depends on how you define roles.

Suck is a strong word but the idea isn't wrong. Yeah, RDMs weren't bad at anything, but in MMO terms "not bad" may was well be worthless when you could have "great" instead. RDMs were really great at a few specific things and decent at everything else. Decent is fine when you're solo but meaningless in a party setting when people want efficiency.

But RDMs can heal, nuke, melee, tank, etc, all with just a quick gear swap! Yeah, but did anyone actually let you do any of those things? I spent a lot of years as a 75 RDM and my memories mostly involve main heal or GTFO. In a party I was there for cure, haste, refresh, sleep, and occasionally chainspell>stun. The only time I got to do other stuff was solo or messing around in small groups.

Slow to get back for the reply, but Karlina basically covered it. The MMO meta doesn't really want 2nd or 3rd string anything when the 1st rate options are available. This point is further emphasized when a given piece of content limits your party size for whatever reason. How things fall in the pecking order is something you'd further have to math down. 5% difference? Probably not so bad. 30% difference or more? Yeah, get out.

Something I frequently encountered back in the day while clamoring for buffs to melee game were people who felt the class would become both OP and that no on would ever play anything else. Now, buffs is a broad term, and I'd even broken down the weaknesses of RDM's melee game into multiple points at that time. Things like gear availability (including inventory restrictions), WS access, food options, TP feed, unique benefits, and then some were all facets I tried to approach the argument from. Some counters simply came from embittered WHMs angry about RDMs stealing their role as healer. Some came from RDMs themselves who didn't want to have to get new gear or (re)learn the job to play it to a new standard. Others were just plain stuck in that zone of irrationality where just because they couldn't see it working, no one else must be able to. Oh, and because some people poopsocked some HNMs, we weren't allowed nice things, either.

In the end, XI's RDM was in somewhat of an awkward place, in part due to gear swapping being a thing. My ultimate take is that if you wanted to melee, subbing WAR or NIN should've been enough with the right gear. Want to heal? /WHM and /SCH. Nuke? /BLM and /SCH, or heck, maybe even /DRK for Stun. But the reality of XI's RDM is that it wound up more mage-heavy as time progressed while playing healer was a low-gear demand side. After all, the expectation was that all you had to do was ride Refresh and Convert, nevermind the other aspect of the equation that involved your party both mitigating damage well and killing mobs in a timely manner. If they failed at that, even the best RDM would eventually run dry. RDM was perhaps "the job" everyone knew how to play, but few wanted to. Why? Well, arguably because a lot of other jobs were more fun and less stress. SE eventually building "better" RDMs through BLU, DNC, and SCH is just a proverbial twist of the dagger.
____________________________
Violence good. **** bad. Yay America.
#24 Jun 16 2016 at 5:25 AM Rating: Good
**
863 posts
Personally I see RDM as a jack of all trades in the sense that I can do a lot of different things depending on the situation and the surroundings. Not everything always. If I am solo I am a beast in every single way, if I am in a larger group I get more of a supportive role or tank (both of which they crushed atm although tanking was nerfed), if I am in a smaller group I get more flexibility in what I do. I was a RDM, BLU and SCH for several years and honestly all I can say is that RDM had everything and I was allowed to use most of it unless I wanted to melee at things like HNM etc.

If all you measure RDM flexibility in is its ability to melee and in how many events it could do it effectively sure then it was not up to snuff so to speak, but honestly to me that is just pigeonholing RDM into something it never was, just something you wanted it to be as well as claiming XI was a very restricted type of game which it never was either. Like I said, I am not saying it was perfect, but I do think they did a great job of making a jack of all trades that fit into the game at basically every level in different ways, just not in every way or a specific way in every situation.
#25 Jun 16 2016 at 6:21 AM Rating: Good
Scholar
****
6,631 posts
I think we will know reasonably soon what jobs be included in 4.0. Based on where the 3.* is right now, I will guess there may be 2 more major updates (up to 3.5) for 3.*. There are probably 1 more addition to Alexander and Sky Pirate raid, and Nidhogg arc is kind of closed now so the story will move toward Warrior of Darkness. My guess is 4.0 be released sometime in the 1st or 2nd quarter of 2017, so info about 4.0 new jobs (and the possibility of red mage) be revealed sometime late summer or in autumn - likely by the North America and Japan fanfest.

Anyway it is always fun to guess. I do think by FFXIV mechanics, it is not easy to introduce hybrid jobs (as other posters have indicated). Rather than "red mage" as a hybrid caster, it is probably better to introduce red mage as a magic sword enchanter class, and it probably make story consistent sense considering what we know about the dual at the end of 2.*. I actually prefered that our lovely lalafell queen to stay dead from our Ala Mingo magic sword user as I think it will giving better options in plot twists in 3.0; instead we get a Deux Ex Machina from Lolorita intervention. Plot wise, I actually think it is harder to introduce Samurai as I don't think foreshadowing is clear (the foreshadowing for Machinst and Astrologer were quite clear even some players may have overlooked them). If anything, watch out what happen in that side plot with our Lalafell - Mithra duo with the masked guy. It may tell us what the new jobs be.

Edited, Jun 16th 2016 8:23am by scchan

Edited, Jun 16th 2016 8:24am by scchan
____________________________
Amanada (Cerberus-Retired) (aka MaiNoKen/Steven)
-- Thank you for the fun times in Vana'diel

Art for the sake of art itself is an idle sentence.
Art for the sake of truth, for the sake of what is
beautiful and good — that is the creed I seek.
- George Sand

A designer knows he has achieved perfection,
not when there is nothing left to add,
but when there is nothing left to take away.
- Antoine de Saint-Exupéry
#26 Jun 16 2016 at 6:34 AM Rating: Good
**
863 posts
Fanfests are like Oct for NA and Dec for JP unless I am mistaking so will probably have to wait until December before we know.
#27 Jun 16 2016 at 7:04 AM Rating: Good
Scholar
****
6,631 posts
Belcrono wrote:
Fanfests are like Oct for NA and Dec for JP unless I am mistaking so will probably have to wait until December before we know.


That is correct. That is why it is good timing to do announcements for 4.0. Don't forget TGS 2016 is mid September as well.
____________________________
Amanada (Cerberus-Retired) (aka MaiNoKen/Steven)
-- Thank you for the fun times in Vana'diel

Art for the sake of art itself is an idle sentence.
Art for the sake of truth, for the sake of what is
beautiful and good — that is the creed I seek.
- George Sand

A designer knows he has achieved perfection,
not when there is nothing left to add,
but when there is nothing left to take away.
- Antoine de Saint-Exupéry
#28 Jun 16 2016 at 2:29 PM Rating: Good
Guru
Avatar
*****
11,143 posts
Belcrono wrote:
Personally I see RDM as a jack of all trades in the sense that I can do a lot of different things depending on the situation and the surroundings. Not everything always. If I am solo I am a beast in every single way, if I am in a larger group I get more of a supportive role or tank (both of which they crushed atm although tanking was nerfed), if I am in a smaller group I get more flexibility in what I do. I was a RDM, BLU and SCH for several years and honestly all I can say is that RDM had everything and I was allowed to use most of it unless I wanted to melee at things like HNM etc.

If all you measure RDM flexibility in is its ability to melee and in how many events it could do it effectively sure then it was not up to snuff so to speak, but honestly to me that is just pigeonholing RDM into something it never was, just something you wanted it to be as well as claiming XI was a very restricted type of game which it never was either. Like I said, I am not saying it was perfect, but I do think they did a great job of making a jack of all trades that fit into the game at basically every level in different ways, just not in every way or a specific way in every situation.


One of the long standing issues was that if you were meleeing, the content was likely inconsequential. This meant you weren't getting good drops. You weren't getting good EXP. The enjoyment of doing so was basically mutually exclusive. That's what I, and others who felt similarly, wanted things to change for so very long. What you perceive in pigeonholing would have, in actuality, been an increase to flexibility. You still could've backlined if that was your thing, but not getting ridiculed out of the party if you didn't was the goal.

If you take the time to go through each expansion and cap increase, you'd find that RDM's gear selection was pretty pathetic in this front. When it came to Zilart, the standout items were a Joyeuse, Peacock Charm, Dusk Gloves/Boots, Scorpion Harness, Amemet +1, Sniper Rings, Suppa, and if you were really lucky/rich, a Speed Belt. This didn't change much with CoP, only adding Brutal Earring, Rajas Ring, and Swift Belt as the poor man's alternative to Speed. If you happened to like the dagger side, Blau was a thing, too. ToAU comes and the only new melee pieces we got were the Goliard Saio and Walahra Turban with their Hastes, the former sacrificing ACC similar to the Rajas/Sniper exchange. WotG was also pretty bleak under the 75 cap. Come 80, we were only on Teal, which was obviously not a melee set. Our weapon options did gain some variety with magian trials, but Joyeuse was still pretty much king. 90 cap, the biggest benefits we saw came through a combination of Composure and Empy+2. Instead of triggering our 30s buff cycle every 2:30, we acquired the luxury of lasting about 3x as long. Gaining 1:30 of swing time is certainly good for the parse, but we're still starting behind other classes when it comes to lower skill ratings, restricted WS, and no melee-related JAs. As an ironic reminder here, the Fencer class never did get the Fencer JT. Go fig. Further, it took a buff to SCH to get our Enspell accuracy more where it should've been with on-cast Enhancing being logged instead of being on-strike. T2 Enspells were still a joke, though. Fast forward to 99 cap and pre-ilvl options were mainly slight upgrades, perhaps sidegrades. After all this, when I assert the job stagnated for the better of a decade, I'm really not kidding.

During the CoP era, getting the Homam set would've been a big deal. When you realize BLU's relic body had Refresh and was a decent melee piece, that did its part in stoking some envy. I guess I forgot Morrigan's body in the above, but Salvage was an event I personally loathed so that doesn't surprise me too much. Still, there wasn't really a melee gear combo where if someone looked at the RDM, they'd think, "I want them in my party!" Nah, consensus usually settled along the lines of, "Not in MY party!" Things are better in ilvl now, particularly with well augmented Taeon and some other buffs, but old habits die hard. Doesn't much help that XI's current endgame also isn't all that melee friendly to begin with. Simplistic ideal: RDMs would open SCs for the heavier hitters and then burst on them to make up the difference, if not exceed it. Maybe I'm just weird in thinking that wasn't too much ask for then and now.
____________________________
Violence good. **** bad. Yay America.
#29 Jun 17 2016 at 9:13 AM Rating: Decent
Scholar
***
1,726 posts
Thayos wrote:
I'd totally play as a melee-heavy rdm with white/black enspells and little-to-no healing.


I would too as long as it was not this stupid rotations garbage.. But that does sound cool...

I do not know if I will even be playing though at that time.
I may have picked up the game for the last time the other day..
Went to do the latest patch and do story line and hit a dungeon and my I-level was too low.
I really do not want to spam dungeons for tomes anymore. There is not craft-able gear worth a crap and most is so expensive to make it aint worth it.
____________________________
FFXI: Nashred
Server: Phoenix

FFXIV : Sir Nashred
server: Ultros
#30 Jun 17 2016 at 9:36 AM Rating: Excellent
Quote:
I do not know if I will even be playing though at that time.
I may have picked up the game for the last time the other day..
Went to do the latest patch and do story line and hit a dungeon and my I-level was too low.
I really do not want to spam dungeons for tomes anymore.


These could be lyrics to a sad, sad song.
____________________________
Thayos Redblade
Jormungandr
Hyperion
#31 Jun 17 2016 at 11:01 AM Rating: Decent
Scholar
***
1,726 posts
Thayos wrote:
Quote:
I do not know if I will even be playing though at that time.
I may have picked up the game for the last time the other day..
Went to do the latest patch and do story line and hit a dungeon and my I-level was too low.
I really do not want to spam dungeons for tomes anymore.


These could be lyrics to a sad, sad song.


LOL

It is sad, I had hope for a long time and lost it several months ago.
Put allot of time into the game. We bough two PS3 and then two PS4 just for the game, so allot of money.
At this point we are just so lost in gaming.

Really thinking of selling the ps4 and getting a couple of pc's and just playing FFXI since there is allot to do but really does not require a ton of time.
Collecting alter ego's, monster raising all sounds more fun.. Now collecting mounts too.. Need to find a better server at this point, ours is mostly Japanese.

Collecting minions and mounts in FFXIV would be cool but most seem to go to the cash shop now, so if you want a complete set you have to purchase it. . It would not be bad if they were offered in the game too, It would give people something to do. Who wants to pay cash for something, what is the challenge in that?

I told Tesee to sell the house since it worth a fortune so if the game ever gets better and we comeback she at least has the cash since they will take the house away.. ( see their was still hope in that last sentence)



Edited, Jun 17th 2016 1:38pm by Nashred
____________________________
FFXI: Nashred
Server: Phoenix

FFXIV : Sir Nashred
server: Ultros
#32 Jun 17 2016 at 1:48 PM Rating: Good
Scholar
****
6,631 posts
Nashred wrote:
Thayos wrote:
Quote:
I do not know if I will even be playing though at that time.
I may have picked up the game for the last time the other day..
Went to do the latest patch and do story line and hit a dungeon and my I-level was too low.
I really do not want to spam dungeons for tomes anymore.


These could be lyrics to a sad, sad song.


LOL

It is sad, I had hope for a long time and lost it several months ago.
Put allot of time into the game. We bough two PS3 and then two PS4 just for the game, so allot of money.
At this point we are just so lost in gaming.

Really thinking of selling the ps4 and getting a couple of pc's and just playing FFXI since there is allot to do but really does not require a ton of time.
Collecting alter ego's, monster raising all sounds more fun.. Now collecting mounts too.. Need to find a better server at this point, ours is mostly Japanese.

Collecting minions and mounts in FFXIV would be cool but most seem to go to the cash shop now, so if you want a complete set you have to purchase it. . It would not be bad if they were offered in the game too, It would give people something to do. Who wants to pay cash for something, what is the challenge in that?

I told Tesee to sell the house since it worth a fortune so if the game ever gets better and we comeback she at least has the cash since they will take the house away.. ( see their was still hope in that last sentence)

Edited, Jun 17th 2016 1:38pm by Nashred


Sometime you cannot really blame there is a cash shop to sell some desirable item. The cost of operating and developing MMO is not low. The cash shop serves as a place to sell some glamour item to keep the game more financially sustainable. Square-Enix had struggled to just to break even many times in the last decade or so. One may have gaming ideals, but hard and cold cash calls the balls and strikes; welcome to the Brave New World of Capitalism. The devs do put the most rare and useful items to be only acquirable in the game, so I think it is fair compromise.

Anyway nowadays, I just game if I feel like too. There are moments that I got frustrated or bored with certain games, it just means it is a nice time to take a break. Best approach I think is that don't worry what you miss if you don't log in, and the devs make it easy to suspend account fees. :-)


Edited, Jun 17th 2016 3:49pm by scchan
____________________________
Amanada (Cerberus-Retired) (aka MaiNoKen/Steven)
-- Thank you for the fun times in Vana'diel

Art for the sake of art itself is an idle sentence.
Art for the sake of truth, for the sake of what is
beautiful and good — that is the creed I seek.
- George Sand

A designer knows he has achieved perfection,
not when there is nothing left to add,
but when there is nothing left to take away.
- Antoine de Saint-Exupéry
#33 Jun 19 2016 at 8:00 PM Rating: Decent
Scholar
**
972 posts
Nashred wrote:
Thayos wrote:
Quote:
I do not know if I will even be playing though at that time.
I may have picked up the game for the last time the other day..
Went to do the latest patch and do story line and hit a dungeon and my I-level was too low.
I really do not want to spam dungeons for tomes anymore.


These could be lyrics to a sad, sad song.


LOL

It is sad, I had hope for a long time and lost it several months ago.
Put allot of time into the game. We bough two PS3 and then two PS4 just for the game, so allot of money.
At this point we are just so lost in gaming.

Really thinking of selling the ps4 and getting a couple of pc's and just playing FFXI since there is allot to do but really does not require a ton of time.
Collecting alter ego's, monster raising all sounds more fun.. Now collecting mounts too.. Need to find a better server at this point, ours is mostly Japanese.

Collecting minions and mounts in FFXIV would be cool but most seem to go to the cash shop now, so if you want a complete set you have to purchase it. . It would not be bad if they were offered in the game too, It would give people something to do. Who wants to pay cash for something, what is the challenge in that?

I told Tesee to sell the house since it worth a fortune so if the game ever gets better and we comeback she at least has the cash since they will take the house away.. ( see their was still hope in that last sentence)



Edited, Jun 17th 2016 1:38pm by Nashred

I would tell you come play Elder Scrolls Online with me. It's closer to FFXI than XIV is. However they are doing some big overhauls like battle scaling and removing alliance segregation. So I don't know what else they are planning. It seems the game goes through pretty big changes often.

Take a look at Pantheon if FFXI isn't doing it for you anymore.

http://www.mmorpg.com/gamelist.cfm/game/1006/feature/10902/Pantheon-Rise-of-the-Fallen-Feature-Spotlight-Perception-System.html


Edited, Jun 19th 2016 10:03pm by sandpark
#34 Jun 20 2016 at 1:56 AM Rating: Good
**
863 posts
I was actually starting to get a little bit interested in ESO, but then I saw the scaling changes that are coming and that more or less killed all interested I had for the game.

Pantheon looks a lot like a newer version of Everquest to me, which is a good thing. Been following it for a long time and definitely think it will be a game I enjoy as long as they make sure to make the game complete before releasing. I really like that the mmorpg market is changing to cater more to everyone by games being more nische instead of having every developer just trying to do the same thing.

Anyway Nashred hope you guys find a game you can enjoy again :)
#35 Jun 28 2016 at 12:02 PM Rating: Decent
Scholar
***
1,726 posts
sandpark wrote:
Nashred wrote:
Thayos wrote:
Quote:
I do not know if I will even be playing though at that time.
I may have picked up the game for the last time the other day..
Went to do the latest patch and do story line and hit a dungeon and my I-level was too low.
I really do not want to spam dungeons for tomes anymore.


These could be lyrics to a sad, sad song.


LOL

It is sad, I had hope for a long time and lost it several months ago.
Put allot of time into the game. We bough two PS3 and then two PS4 just for the game, so allot of money.
At this point we are just so lost in gaming.

Really thinking of selling the ps4 and getting a couple of pc's and just playing FFXI since there is allot to do but really does not require a ton of time.
Collecting alter ego's, monster raising all sounds more fun.. Now collecting mounts too.. Need to find a better server at this point, ours is mostly Japanese.

Collecting minions and mounts in FFXIV would be cool but most seem to go to the cash shop now, so if you want a complete set you have to purchase it. . It would not be bad if they were offered in the game too, It would give people something to do. Who wants to pay cash for something, what is the challenge in that?

I told Tesee to sell the house since it worth a fortune so if the game ever gets better and we comeback she at least has the cash since they will take the house away.. ( see their was still hope in that last sentence)



Edited, Jun 17th 2016 1:38pm by Nashred

I would tell you come play Elder Scrolls Online with me. It's closer to FFXI than XIV is. However they are doing some big overhauls like battle scaling and removing alliance segregation. So I don't know what else they are planning. It seems the game goes through pretty big changes often.

Take a look at Pantheon if FFXI isn't doing it for you anymore.

http://www.mmorpg.com/gamelist.cfm/game/1006/feature/10902/Pantheon-Rise-of-the-Fallen-Feature-Spotlight-Perception-System.html


Edited, Jun 19th 2016 10:03pm by sandpark


Picked up elder scrolls online for PS4 to at least give it a try..
____________________________
FFXI: Nashred
Server: Phoenix

FFXIV : Sir Nashred
server: Ultros
#36 Sep 02 2016 at 7:50 PM Rating: Decent
Avatar
****
7,546 posts
Hello did someone say RDM my ears were burning.

I have put some thought into how RDM would work in FF14 since 1.0, and frankly as a self proclaimed RDM know it all...I don't think it would work in the traditional aspect of the job, at least not in 14, there is no room for functionality of a true Jack of All Trades. Of course that doesn't mean you can't put it into a role.

Personally I think it would be super interesting as a Support/Tank role. Something that doesn't exist. We have 2 Support/DPS Roles (MCH, BRD), and we have a Support/Healer role (AST), I think RDM could function well in this role while maintaining some semblance of its "traditional" Self.

I think that something like Enspells dictating "stance" would be interesting perhaps something like

Enlight = Standard Role Support = Reduced Mob Evasion while Enlight is applied.
= This would result in an applied uptick in raid wide DPS similar to how other support can increase raid DPS through TP Regen, MP Regen, removing the dependency of ACC Food/Melds in favor of extra ATK Food or Melds

EnDark = Stanard Tanking Role = Reduced Mob Damage (direct attacks) while EnDark is applied.
= This would functionally result in the same effect as direct damage reduction other tanks have...but also apply it to the raid, so if someone pulls hate and EnDark is being applied...then they too will get a defensive bonus applied (make sense)

In addition to the stances there should be other support oriented functions, for Cooldowns I like stealing names from FFXI SCs as they associate themselves with the WHM/BLM mix in elements.

Distortion ICE/WATER could be a DoT or something that adds a Slow or Paralyze
Fragmentation THUNDER/WIND could be a Burst Damage with a Stun
Fusion FIRE/LIGHT could be a Dot that restores HP % on damage dealt
Gravitation EARTH/DARK could be a Burst Damage that restores MP or TP on damage dealt

Nice elemental synergy between WHM and BLM I think, while supporting the Tank role.

As for Weaponskill/Ability Progression.

I like the idea of mixing up the methods a bit.

Main DPS I think would be cool to have WS, WS, Spell like a SC + MB
Shining Blade > Vorpal Blade > Ultima

Secondary DPS I would like WS, Spell, Spell
Shining Blade > Gravity (Returns MP/TP) > Dia (DOT)

And Primary threat Rotation would be WS/WS/WS
Shining Blade > Vorpal Blade > Requiscat

And of course one or two defensive CDs
Phalanx - Reduces Physical Damage
Shell- Reduces Magic Damage

Yes I am stoned.
RDD Out.
____________________________
HEY GOOGLE. **** OFF YOU. **** YOUR ******** SEARCH ENGINE IN ITS ******* ****** BINARY ***. ALL DAY LONG.

Necro Warning: This post occurred more than thirty days after the prior, and may be a necropost.
#37 Oct 17 2016 at 11:01 AM Rating: Decent
1 post
I think exploring the balance of white and black magic would be an excellent story for Rdm. I also think that they could incorporate that into their play mechanics as well with a balancing scale (similar to Blm but involving melee). Their abilities could be augmented based upon what type of magic you choose to couple in with your combos for melee. Possibly have them using more white magic moves could augment the end result of combos to provide buffs. And Black magic would provide enfeebles. There's so many options on how they could make them it's a bit insane. Hopefully they go beyond the traditional rotation/placement method.
Necro Warning: This post occurred more than thirty days after the prior, and may be a necropost.
Reply To Thread

Colors Smileys Quote OriginalQuote Checked Help

 

Recent Visitors: 167 All times are in CDT
Anonymous Guests (167)