There are so many crappy reviews I'm not wasting my time right now entering the dates the reviews came out in http://ffxiv.zam.com/forum.html?game=268&mid=1286440973230306149
but as soon as SE patches and fixes problems and the good reviews start coming out I'll add the dates so people can see the evolution of the game.
They wont re-review the game except for ps3 and wow you sure are confident they will fix the game instead of either make it worse or underwhelm everyone, nobody thought they would release the beta in such a stinking state but they did, or that beta bar a few minor fixes would be final but it was. What makes you think the same dev team will get it right after getting oh so wrong the first try?
I've had much experience with this dev team and their stubborn attitudes over the years, there is zero guarantee the patches will fix the game to a point where it's considered good. They could make it worse, the patch could be underwhelming or they could make things better but it wont be some miracle patch that makes an unplayable disaster into the the next FFXI or more. The more you play up this patch the more likely it is to be letdown.
Keep in mind there is a limit to how much of a re-write they can actually do, a lot of the game is now set in stone. They don't make a game for you as you want it, they let you play the game they made as they want it. Thats how they have always shown themselves to think anyway.