See this is the hyrist I LIKE!!!
First off we where speaking strictly of combat, wish as you have pointed out, both run on cooldowns, and yes other resources as well, for Both:)
As for the feel, well we cant talk about that, since there is no feel to speak off, since 2.0 is not out, and whatever we saw, was just walking, jumping etc etc, from that we can gather that 2.0 combat system will be pretty much your generic MMO combat system with a "Limit Break" added for flavor, again we have not been given any type of information as to what "Limit Breaks" will bring and if there are a variation of them, if you have different classes.
As for the lack of aeirial combat, true tsk tsk is that bad or good ? for me more variety is better, as for PVP, well we sure know wish game lacks that dont we ? and wish game is gonna add it ? Oh wish game is it ? FFXIV.(Wish btw i can assure you will bring a lot of problems :) )
As for the planet and if is inside out or whatever, that is lore related, want to talk about lore ? let's see what game, is literally replicating other mmo's ? Let's see in wish MMO'S have there been a "Cataclyst" or "Event" where the world has been changed in order to justify a redesign of the world etc etc.... Hmm Maybe Everquest ? Maybe Wow ? Tsk Tsk!! **** even FFVII.... Wish btw kinda sad seeing FFXIV resorting to literally borrowing concepts directly from the main series, when FFXI could stand in it's own two legs, yet this one literally remade the garlean empire into the empire of FFVI, and keeps borrowing concepts from FVII(Meteor, Materia, Limit Breaks.) Again FFXI was able to stand on its own 2 feet as far as lore was concerned..... What happened ?
As for chocobos, really ? You did know chocobos are a copy of Horseclaws from Nausicaa valle of the wind.... just saying you should know your Final Fantasy History....
As for classes... Novel concept, that so far has been lackluster, in fact one would consider it was nerfed with the current limitations it got, considering the orignal idea was much more "Freer" so to speak.
As for crafting.... Really FFXIV crafting sucks. get over it, it sucks, it's complicated for the sake of being complicated, and if 2.0 dreams of even being on the same market as it's competitors it will get nerfed to the ground :) (Just as classes will once PVP is released)