Kanji Create Atmosphere -- Of Controversy

Chocobos are called horse-birds now -- it's true.  Don't try to fight it; your character will be deleted if you even type "chocobo" into the chat bar.  Now, fly, my minions and spread these words across the Internet!

OK, now if there are any people left reading this -- people who don't have an axe to grind against Square Enix -- let's look at what is really going on here.

Kanji and controversy, my two favorite things to write about.

Look, I have levied my fair share of criticism against Square Enix, and I will point out, let's say, an error in judgement now and again.  However, this latest outrage is misplaced to some extent.  Maybe I'm just biased in my passion for studying kanji, but there is a legitimate other side to this story, too.  

People like to point to Japanese forums as the be-all end-all of the state of Final Fantasy XIV.  In some cases, they are helpful for early news and inside information because so many publications and interviews only release in Japan.  However, in other cases, they can be just as misinformed and quick to lash out as a troll running through our very forums.  If there's any meme that transcends borders, it is "haters gonna hate."

So, the source of the rage is a thread on 2ch in which players noticed that in the version Japanese version of Final Fantasy XIV, チョコボ (Chocobo) has been replaced with the term 馬鳥, which is literally horse + bird.  Soon, blogs were reporting on the thread, and eventually overseas gaming sites picked up on the story as well.  As you can read in the link at the beginning of the article, this stylistic choice has blossomed into a full-fledged conspiracy, with people claiming Square Enix has developed the game in China, or at least intentionally designed it to appeal to Chinese.

Now, it is true that in some instances, Japanese players will see an ideograph meaning "horse-bird."  For instance, Chocobo Blood and Chocobo Feather use the infamous "horse-bird" term, but Chocobo Fly and Chocobotail Saw use the traditional katakana "Chocobo."  Chocobo as animals are 馬鳥, and things produced from Chocobo are labeled "Chocobo [item name]."

Kanji represent ideas and concepts.  Just like a woodpecker is 啄木鳥 (ki-tsu-tsu-ki, a tree peckingbird), 馬鳥 is a bird that is mounted and ridden like a horse --  a horse-bird.  However, both of these terms are read in ways that defy the standard readings assigned to their kanji.  These are called ateji 当て字 -- kanji used for their meaning independent of their reading.  So, 馬鳥 is not a replacement name for Chocobo, but rather serves as a visual representation of the what a Chocobo is for the purposes of the written language of Eorzea.

Does that make any sense?  Just trying to make this comprehensible was a chore, so I'm sure you are asking "what is the point of all this?"  Well, as is often the case recently, the answer can be found on Producer Hiromichi Tanka's Twitter feed:

XI had this as well, but Chinese-sounding names are a simple way to create a different cultural atmosphere as opposed to English-sounding names.  This so-called "Japan-made Chinese" is comprised of words created by Japanese people, so I'm thinking they will be translated differently in the actual Chinese version of the game.

Tanaka and the developers wanted to create a different atmosphere in Eorzea.  It's a medieval, fantastical land with a rich and detailed history. This is quite noticeable in the English version of the game as well, with word choice alone creating its own buzz.  To put it simply: Old-timey Japanese is Chinese.  The farther back you go in Japanese literature, the more and more influence you see from China.  In fact, many idioms and proverbs are adapted from Chinese sayings and expanded into Japanese sentences.

To add further explanation, an apology notice was also issued on the official beta tester site.  There, World Concept Planner Kenichi Iwao explained that beyond creating a certain atmosphere for Eorzea, excessive use of English loan-words might be confusing.  Using kanji-based terms let's any player understand what an item is without extensive knowledge of Final Fantasy or role-playing games.

Let's take one of the controversial changes as listed by Japanese bloggers as an example: Mythril.  Usually, mythril, as an English word created by J.R.R. Tolkien, is put into katakana (ミスリル).  In FFXIV, they use 霊銀 (rei-gin) which is silver infused with spiritual or elemental power.  However, it is again only used in specific cases.  The kanji term is used for Mythril Ore, while the phonetic English term is used for Mythril-based products like this lovely Mythril Wristlet. So, the idea here is that "spiritual silver" written in kanji gives the player a better grasp of the concept of Mythril while equipment made from this mineral is still called "Mythril" equipment.

Anyway, I love this stuff; I could go on for hours, but I'll wrap things up here.  Personally, I think the choices Square Enix have made regarding language-use are very interesting.  At the same time, I can also understand the frustration some players are feeling.  Final Fantasy XI was already fairly kanji-heavy, and FFXIV has really dialed that way up.  There are many cases of common kanji being swapped out for older alternatives, and some of the terms are kind of awkward and are more suited for a historical real-time strategy game.

So what does Square Enix think? Well, they agree! In addition to using their beta site apology to promise changes, Tanaka tweeted up again and pointed (or passed the buck, depending on who you ask) to World Concept Planner Iwao for including the large amount of difficult kanji. Referencing "horse-bird" directly, Tanaka admitted that there are some confusing terms, which they plan to fix.

Bottom line, your Chocobo is here to stay.


Post Comment
# Sep 21 2010 at 8:53 AM Rating: Good
303 posts
The "horseBird" thing was because FF wasn't realesed in china before therefore don't know what a chocobo is, that's the only reasonable explaination for the name change.
Busaman the Mighty wrote:
Man I barely remember life before wow. It was hard living in caves for shelter and fending off wild beasts with only a sharpened stick. Men women and children all dying from simple infections Food was scarce, sometimes all we had to eat would be a fallen member of the tribe.

Those were dark days indeed. Thank Raptor Jesus for delivering us from our sins with his only son, the World Of Warcraft

oh man
# Sep 21 2010 at 8:38 AM Rating: Decent
17 posts
I'm gonna out level you
Made sense
# Sep 21 2010 at 7:34 AM Rating: Decent
14 posts
I'm not sure why everyone though tries to jump the gun on what may be different or changed before the final product release, trying to be the "first" to find an error or change. Place holders are used all the time in unfinished products and yes sometimes they are left behind when they are finished and released but that would seem the more appropriate time to then submit a ticket and let them know that something doesn't seem right.

I think it doesn't help that people are already hyped up over the fatigue/xp system that is being incorporated. I'm all for new ideas and if it doesn't work out then it gets a major overall in a patch or an expansion later on, and so it goes.
you asked, i answered, why are you still bothering me with this?
Common & Proper?
# Sep 21 2010 at 4:55 AM Rating: Decent
1 post
So, "common nouns/items" are given in descriptive kanji, and "proper nouns/designed items" are given their traditional monikers? Cool, though, yeah, a bit disorienting.
# Sep 20 2010 at 10:17 PM Rating: Excellent
118 posts
The master said: Haters gonna hate.
Post Comment

Free account required to post

You must log in or create an account to post messages.